15 Most Affordable Neighborhoods in Green Bay, WI

Did you know that Green Bay’s median home price is nearly 30% lower than the national average? As the smallest city to host an NFL team, Green Bay offers an incredible mix of small-town charm and big-city amenities – without the hefty price tag! I’ll guide you through the most affordable neighborhoods in Green Bay From historic districts to up-and-coming areas, let’s explore where you can find the best value for your housing dollar in Titletown!

Understanding Green Bay’s Housing Market

When you really start to look at the Green Bay Housing market, you will be amazed by how diverse and dynamic it is for a mid-sized city. Whether you’re buying, renting, or just exploring, there’s something for everyone—if you know where to look. Let me walk you through some key insights I’ve picked up along the way.

Current Median Home Prices and Rental Rates

The median home price in Green Bay hovers around $250,000 as of late 2024. Compared to national averages, that’s a steal! Rentals are also fairly affordable, with a typical two-bedroom apartment going for about $1,200 per month, though you can find cheaper options in certain neighborhoods. For context, Green Bay’s cost of living is about 15% lower than the U.S. average, making it a hotspot for those looking for affordable housing options. But here’s the catch: inventory can be tight, especially for starter homes or fixer-upper properties in popular areas.

Market Trends and Predictions for 2024

Green Bay’s housing market has been steady but not without its quirks. In 2024, we’re seeing a subtle shift towards a seller’s market. Rising mortgage rates have slowed buying a bit, but rental demand is climbing. Neighborhoods like Astor and Whitney Park are seeing increased interest from investors. If you’re thinking about buying, keep an eye on Whitney Park, as it’s poised for growth thanks to urban development projects.

Comparison to Other Wisconsin Cities

Compared to cities like Madison or Milwaukee, Green Bay offers more affordable housing without sacrificing amenities. Madison’s median home price is pushing $400,000, and Milwaukee’s rental market is notably pricier, with two-bedroom apartments averaging around $1,700 monthly. Green Bay stands out as a sweet spot—not too small, not too pricey. Plus, you get that unique mix of urban convenience and small-town charm.

Impact of Packers’ Presence on Local Real Estate

Ah, the Packers effect! It’s no secret that Green Bay’s housing market feels the ripple of this NFL powerhouse. Homes near Lambeau Field come with a premium, especially during the season. Rental properties in this area are hot commodities for short-term leases, with Airbnb hosts charging up to $400 per night on game weekends. The presence of the team has also led to steady investment in the area, boosting property values and keeping neighborhoods vibrant year-round. If you’re a die-hard fan, snagging a place nearby might be worth the splurge—but act fast because inventory here is always tight.


Most Affordable East Side Neighborhoods

As you begin to explore Green Bay’s East Side, you will be pleasantly surprised by how much charm and affordability it offers. Whether you’re looking for a starter home or a budget-friendly apartment, neighborhoods like Astor, Joannes Park, and Downtown Green Bay deliver a lot of bang for your buck. Plus, the area is packed with local gems, so you’re not sacrificing lifestyle for cost. Let’s dive into what makes these neighborhoods so special.

Astor

Astor is like stepping into a postcard. The neighborhood’s historic vibe is anchored by gorgeous older homes, many of which are priced around $175,000 to $225,000. If you’re into historic districts, Astor is the place to be—it’s home to some of the oldest and most architecturally interesting properties in Green Bay. Rental options here are surprisingly affordable too, with cozy apartments starting at about $900 a month. Plus, you’re walking distance from parks, coffee shops, and the iconic Fox River Trail. Honestly, living here feels like being part of Green Bay’s history.

Joannes Park

If you want something affordable but with a bit more space, Joannes Park is a hidden gem. Homes here are often in the $150,000 to $200,000 range, making it one of the East Side’s best options for budget-conscious buyers. Rentals are equally appealing, with single-family homes available for around $1,100 to $1,300 per month. The park itself is a huge perk—think green spaces for picnics, sports, and even a small water feature for kids in the summer. And if you’re into bowling or casual dining, there are a few mom-and-pop spots nearby that keep the vibe friendly and low-key.

Downtown Green Bay

For anyone who loves a mix of urban energy and small-town charm, Downtown Green Bay hits the sweet spot. It’s a bit pricier than Astor or Joannes Park, with homes averaging between $200,000 and $275,000, but the convenience is worth every penny. Renting downtown is also doable, with sleek apartments available for around $1,400 a month. The best part? You’re steps away from the Farmer’s Market on Broadway, tons of locally owned restaurants, and the waterfront. Living downtown means you can leave your car behind and enjoy a truly walkable neighborhood.

Costs of Typical Homes and Rentals

Overall, the East Side is a haven for affordable housing compared to Green Bay’s West Side or suburbs. While neighborhoods like Astor lean historic, Joannes Park offers modest homes, and Downtown adds a dash of city life. Homes are mostly in the $150,000 to $250,000 range, while rentals run between $900 and $1,400 a month, depending on size and amenities. The combination of low prices and access to key amenities like parks, schools, and shops makes this area a no-brainer for budget-conscious folks.

Local Amenities and Attractions

What really makes the East Side special are the little details—like being close to Bay Beach Amusement Park or grabbing brunch at a cozy café on the weekends. There are plenty of walking trails, locally owned boutiques, and even some live music spots that add a unique flavor to the area. Plus, the East Side’s proximity to UW-Green Bay makes it a solid option for students and faculty looking for affordable living.

Budget-Friendly West Side Areas

When I first started exploring Green Bay’s West Side, I wasn’t sure what to expect. East Side neighborhoods like Astor and Joannes Park tend to steal the spotlight, but the West Side quietly offers some of the best affordable housing in town. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, a renter on a budget, or even looking for an investment property, neighborhoods like Fort Howard, Tank Park, and Western Heights deserve a closer look. Each has its own unique vibe, with plenty of features and facilities that make them great places to live.

Fort Howard

Fort Howard has this old-school charm that’s hard to resist. The homes here are mostly modest single-family houses, often priced in the $125,000 to $180,000 range. For renters, the area is a steal, with cozy apartments available for as low as $800 per month. What I love about Fort Howard is how community-focused it feels. You’ll find local parks perfect for weekend soccer games or picnics, and the area’s proximity to downtown makes it easy to get to restaurants and shopping without a long drive. Plus, if you’re into Green Bay’s history, the neighborhood is dotted with historical markers that give you a glimpse into the city’s past.

Tank Park

If you’re looking for a tight-knit, family-friendly neighborhood, Tank Park is a top pick. Homes here are a bit newer than in Fort Howard, with prices ranging from $140,000 to $200,000. The neighborhood gets its name from Tank Park itself, a small but well-kept green space with playground equipment and shaded picnic spots. I’ve always thought Tank Park had a quiet charm—it’s the kind of place where neighbors wave as you pass by and kids ride their bikes safely down the street. The area also has quick access to some solid schools and grocery stores, making it a practical choice for families.

Western Heights

Now, Western Heights is where you’ll find a mix of affordable housing and a surprising amount of space. Many of the homes here sit on larger lots, which is great if you’re into gardening or just like a bit more breathing room. Average home prices are slightly higher, hovering between $150,000 and $225,000, but for what you’re getting, it’s worth it. Rentals in this area are harder to come by, but when they pop up, they’re usually in the $1,000 to $1,300 range. One thing I always notice about Western Heights is how peaceful it feels. The streets are lined with mature trees, and the area has a few local diners that give it that classic Midwestern vibe.

Average Property Values

In general, Green Bay’s West Side is one of the most affordable areas in the city. Homes across Fort Howard, Tank Park, and Western Heights average around $150,000 to $200,000, with some fixer-uppers dipping below that and move-in-ready properties climbing slightly higher. Rental prices typically stay in the $800 to $1,300 range, which is great for folks trying to keep housing costs under control. The West Side’s affordability, paired with its quiet streets and proximity to key amenities, makes it an underrated gem for budget-conscious buyers and renters.

Community Features and Facilities

One of the biggest perks of living on the West Side is how convenient it is. You’re close to local grocery stores, schools, and even some great parks like Perkins Park, which has picnic areas, a splash pad, and walking trails. The area also offers easy access to highways, making it a breeze to commute to other parts of Green Bay. Plus, if you’re a fan of the outdoors, the West Side is just a short drive from the Baird Creek Greenway, perfect for hiking and biking. The neighborhoods here also have a strong sense of community, with events like neighborhood clean-ups and block parties that bring everyone together.


Up-and-Coming Affordable Neighborhoods

Green Bay’s housing market has been buzzing lately, and if you’re looking for affordable homes that are on the rise, the Near East Side and Whitney Park neighborhoods are two areas you should definitely have on your radar. These neighborhoods are experiencing noticeable growth thanks to emerging development projects and increasing community interest, making them ideal for first-time buyers or savvy investors. If you’re willing to get in a little early, you might just score a gem before prices start to climb in these up and coming Green Bay Neighborhoods.

Near East Side

The Near East Side has been making waves recently, and it’s not hard to see why. You can still find homes priced around $140,000 to $180,000, but those prices are starting to inch up as new coffee shops, small businesses, and community spaces pop up. The neighborhood has this quirky charm—think mid-century homes mixed with the occasional new build. When I first drove through, I was struck by how many people were out and about. It has this walkable vibe, with local bakeries and parks that are perfect for weekend strolls.

One thing that’s really driving interest here is the redevelopment of older properties into trendy spaces for young professionals and families. If you’re looking to rent, apartments here typically range from $850 to $1,100 a month, which is still affordable compared to downtown. The proximity to Green Bay’s central hub also makes it ideal for folks who want the amenities of city living without paying downtown prices.

Whitney Park

Whitney Park has flown under the radar for years, but not anymore. It’s one of those neighborhoods that’s quietly transforming thanks to community investment programs and a focus on revitalizing older homes. Properties here are still a steal, with typical prices in the $130,000 to $170,000 range, though fixer-uppers can dip below $120,000 if you’re willing to put in the work.

What makes Whitney Park stand out is its central park area, which has become a hub for community events like farmers markets and outdoor movie nights. The neighborhood feels like it’s on the verge of something big. Developers are starting to take notice too—there are plans for a mixed-use building near the park, which could bring in more shops and eateries. It’s also becoming popular with young families thanks to its close proximity to good schools and daycare facilities.

Emerging Development Projects

Both neighborhoods are seeing a wave of infrastructure upgrades and new construction. In the Near East Side, there’s a planned mixed-use development that will include retail space, apartments, and green areas—a mini downtown within a neighborhood. Meanwhile, Whitney Park is seeing smaller but impactful updates, like streetscaping projects and community grants for home renovations.

These upgrades don’t just improve curb appeal; they’re drawing in small businesses. I heard a local coffee roaster is opening a shop in Whitney Park next year, and there’s talk of a co-working space in the Near East Side. These developments often act as magnets, attracting young professionals and first-time buyers.

Investment Potential

If you’re looking to make a smart move, both the Near East Side and Whitney Park offer serious investment potential. With average home prices still below the city median, these areas are primed for appreciation. A recent study on Green Bay real estate trends showed a 6% increase in property values in these neighborhoods over the past year, with projections suggesting even faster growth as development ramps up.

For landlords, the rental market here is heating up. Single-family homes are in demand, and many buyers are turning to house hacking—living in one unit and renting out another. It’s a smart way to offset mortgage costs while riding the wave of rising property values.

Future Growth Predictions

Here’s the thing: These neighborhoods aren’t just about what they are now—they’re about what they’re becoming. Local officials have hinted at more community development grants for Whitney Park, and the Near East Side is expected to benefit from the city’s larger push toward urban renewal. Both areas are also attracting younger residents, which brings energy and boosts the local economy.

In five years, I wouldn’t be surprised if home prices here are 30% higher, especially as the new developments and public improvements start paying off. If you’re on the fence about buying or investing, now might be the time to make your move.


Factors Affecting Neighborhood Affordability

When deciding where to live in Green Bay, affordability goes beyond the price of a home or apartment. There’s a mix of hidden costs and benefits that can make or break your budget. From property tax rates to transportation access, understanding these factors is key to finding a neighborhood that fits your financial and lifestyle needs. Here’s a closer look at the details you should consider.

Property Tax Rates

Property taxes are often overlooked until you’re knee-deep in paperwork, but they play a huge role in your monthly housing expenses. In Green Bay, property tax rates vary depending on the neighborhood and school district. For instance, areas with newer developments or higher-rated schools—like parts of the East Side—might have slightly higher rates. On the other hand, neighborhoods like Tank Park on the West Side often have lower property taxes, making them more budget-friendly.

Additionally new construction can also have a big tax-bill wake up surprise.  Often times when you buy a brand new house, the taxes are based on the land only value, and the next year are re-assessed to the highest use value which includes your new home.  It can be quite a shocker to have a tax bill go from $1,000 per year or less to over $5K!

When I bought my first home, I didn’t factor in the tax bill, and wow, was that a wake-up call! Make sure you look at the mill rate for the area and ask your realtor for an estimate of annual taxes. It can save you from sticker shock later.

School District Quality

Let’s face it: good schools often mean higher housing costs. In Green Bay, neighborhoods served by top-rated schools tend to have more competitive housing markets. For families, this is a priority, but for singles or couples without kids, it might not be worth the premium. For instance, the Howard-Suamico School District is a major draw, but homes in those areas come with a higher price tag.

If schools don’t matter as much to you, consider neighborhoods like Fort Howard or Whitney Park, where the property prices might be lower because they’re not tied to elite school districts. That said, these areas often have growing community programs that make them a great value.

Transportation Access

One thing Green Bay doesn’t always get credit for is its decent public transportation options. Living near a major bus route or with quick highway access can save you time and money, especially if you commute daily. Neighborhoods like Downtown Green Bay or Western Heights have the benefit of being close to work hubs, cutting down on gas costs or bus fares.

But beware—those savings can be offset if you live further out and need a car for everything. I learned this the hard way when I moved to a “cheaper” neighborhood that added 20 minutes to my drive time. Those extra miles added up fast in fuel costs and wear on my car.

Utility Costs

The age and type of housing in a neighborhood also influence utility costs. Older homes, like the charming ones in Astor Park, may come with higher heating bills during Green Bay’s long winters. On the flip side, neighborhoods with newer builds or energy-efficient upgrades—like parts of the Near East Side—can help keep your bills manageable.

Astor East River Trail
Astor East River Trail

If you’re renting, always ask about average utility costs for the unit or house. A low rent price might come with sky-high heating bills in January. Some landlords include utilities in the rent, but don’t assume—always double-check.

Insurance Rates

Insurance isn’t the most glamorous part of homeownership or renting, but it’s another piece of the affordability puzzle. Factors like crime rates, proximity to flood zones, and the age of the home all impact your premiums. For example, homes near the Fox River might require flood insurance, which can add a few hundred dollars to your annual costs.

I once fell in love with a house in a “hot” neighborhood but found out it needed additional coverage because of its location near a high-crime area. It wasn’t a deal-breaker, but it did bump my monthly expenses higher than I’d expected.

The Big Picture

When you’re evaluating affordability, it’s easy to focus on the upfront costs—purchase price, rent, or mortgage. But don’t forget to dig deeper into these additional expenses. Combining all these factors, from property taxes to transportation access, gives you a much clearer picture of what living in a specific neighborhood will actually cost.

My advice? Make a spreadsheet (yes, seriously) and plug in these numbers for each area you’re considering. It might feel nerdy, but knowing exactly where your money is going can help you avoid nasty surprises—and leave more room in your budget for the fun stuff, like decorating your new place!


Tips for Finding Affordable Housing in Green Bay

Hunting for affordable housing in Green Bay can feel like navigating a maze. Between timing the market, tapping into resources, and learning the art of negotiation, it’s a lot to take in. I’ve been through this journey myself, and trust me, a little insider knowledge goes a long way. Here are my best tips to make your search easier—and your wallet happier.

Best Times to Buy/Rent

Timing is everything in real estate, and Green Bay is no exception. If you’re looking to rent, spring and early summer tend to have the most availability. This is when landlords refresh their listings, especially around college areas like the Near East Side. However, if you’re hoping to score a deal, try searching in the off-season—late fall and winter. Fewer people are moving, so you might find landlords and sellers more willing to negotiate.

When buying, keep an eye on listings in late summer. Many sellers want to close before the school year starts, so there’s often room to negotiate if their property hasn’t sold yet. That’s how I snagged my first home—an end-of-August listing with a motivated seller.

Local Assistance Programs

Green Bay offers several housing assistance programs to help make housing more affordable. The Brown County Housing Authority has programs like the Housing Choice Voucher (Section 8) for low-income renters. There’s also the NeighborWorks Green Bay program, which provides homebuyer education and down payment assistance.

I remember hearing about NeighborWorks during my first home search, and honestly, it was a game-changer. They helped me understand the financing process, and I qualified for a small grant that made my down payment less intimidating. If you’re unsure where to start, give them a call—they’re super friendly and knowledgeable.

First-Time Homebuyer Resources

Being a first-time homebuyer is exciting but nerve-wracking. In Green Bay, you have resources like Wisconsin Housing and Economic Development Authority (WHEDA) loans, which offer lower interest rates and reduced down payment requirements. If you’re new to home buying, attending a workshop through NeighborWorks or similar local organizations can give you the confidence to navigate the process.

One thing I learned the hard way? Pre-approval is your best friend. Not only does it help you understand your budget, but it also shows sellers that you’re serious. I’ve seen homes go to buyers who were pre-approved over others who weren’t—even when their offers were slightly lower.

Negotiation Strategies

Negotiation can feel intimidating, especially if you’re not naturally assertive. But here’s the deal (pun intended): Green Bay’s housing market is competitive, but it’s not cutthroat. If you’re buying, don’t be afraid to ask for closing costs to be covered or request a home warranty. Sellers often expect some negotiation, especially if the home has been on the market for a while.

For renters, it’s worth asking if the landlord can include utilities or lower the rent slightly if you’re willing to sign a longer lease. When I rented my first place in Joannes Park, I managed to knock $50 off the monthly rent by offering to sign a two-year lease. It never hurts to ask—you might be surprised at what’s negotiable.

Working with Local Realtors

A good realtor can be your secret weapon when searching for affordable housing in Green Bay. I know the housing market trends, the up-and-coming neighborhoods, and where you might find hidden gems. Look at how many transitions I’ve done, and my overall reviews.

Final Thoughts

Finding affordable housing in Green Bay is part strategy, part patience. Whether you’re renting or buying, timing your search, leveraging local programs, and working with a savvy realtor can make a huge difference. The key is to stay flexible, do your homework, and don’t be afraid to ask questions (or negotiate!).

Trust me, there’s no better feeling than finding a home that fits both your needs and your budget. It might take a little extra work upfront, but the payoff is worth it when you step into a place that feels like yours without breaking the bank.

Conclusion

Green Bay offers numerous affordable neighborhoods that combine value with quality of life. Whether you choose the historic charm of Astor or the family-friendly atmosphere of Western Heights, you’ll find that Green Bay’s housing market provides excellent options for budget-conscious residents. Ready to make your move to Titletown? Connect with a local realtor today to start exploring these affordable neighborhoods in person!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.



Get my Free Lambeau Guide